Qualitative study · Anesthesiology · 2025
“The Pain and Suffering Are Just Too Great for Me to Manage”: A Qualitative Study of Emotional Distress among Anesthesiologists after Challenging Clinical Events
Burns CJ, Marzoughi M, Sinko L, Saddawi‑Konefka D, Stratton K, Sigakis M, Wixson M, Simmons S, Ramirez M, Kheterpal S, Was A. doi:10.1097/ALN.0000000000005660
The question
Anesthesiologists manage acute clinical events, such as an intraoperative death, a medical error, or a bad clinical outcome, that can cause emotional distress. Earlier research asked anesthesiologists to rank a fixed list of outcomes, such as death or cardiac arrest, by how distressing they were. The authors argue that this approach can miss the mix of clinical, contextual, and personal factors involved, and that little was known about why some events leave lasting distress.
The study had two aims. The first was to identify what in the practice environment makes a clinical event distressing. The second was to describe the emotions and symptoms anesthesiologists experience after events they consider distressing over the long term.
What it found
Twenty faculty anesthesiologists from one academic medical center, representing nine subspecialties, each took part in a 30-minute interview. Beforehand, they were asked to reflect on what they considered the most emotionally distressing clinical event of their career, so they came prepared to discuss one specific event. The questions drew on known risk factors for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), both during and after the event. A medical student conducted the interviews to reduce any power imbalance. The primary researcher coded all the interviews, and a second researcher coded every third one. Eleven of the 20 described events that occurred during their residency or fellowship, and the median time between the event and the interview was 6 years.
- Clinical risk factors were an error causing a poor outcome, a first encounter with a clinical scenario, lack of adequate clinical support, and an unanticipated outcome.
- Contextual risk factors were legal and professional repercussions, mistreatment by colleagues outside anesthesiology, underlying life stressors, and unsupportive leadership.
- Patient risk factors were a close relationship with the patient, a patient's relatability to the anesthesiologist or their loved ones, and young patient age.
- Every event described contained multiple risk factors from each of the three categories.
- Participants described guilt, shame, helplessness, sadness, and self-doubt about their clinical skills, along with insomnia, palpitations, flashbacks, and intrusive thoughts. One said, “I would go for a run and be thinking about it. I would take a shower and be thinking about it.”
Why it matters
The study offers a framework for which features of an event, its setting, and the patient involved can make it distressing for an anesthesiologist. The authors conclude that anesthesiologists who experience emotional distress from clinical events describe it as profound and lasting.
The authors call for research on system-level interventions to reduce the emotional impact of these events, for longitudinal studies of how they affect careers, and for quantitative studies of how common secondary traumatic stress symptoms are among anesthesiologists.
These are themes from interviews with 20 anesthesiologists at one academic center, so they describe what this distress looks like rather than how common it is.
How to cite it
Burns CJ, Marzoughi M, Sinko L, et al. “The pain and suffering are just too great for me to manage”: a qualitative study of emotional distress among anesthesiologists after challenging clinical events. Anesthesiology. 2025;143(5):1349-1356. doi:10.1097/ALN.0000000000005660
More on the publications page. The complete record is on PubMed and ORCID.