Survey study · Journal of Education in Perioperative Medicine · 2019
Faculty Underestimate Resident Desire for Constructive Feedback and Overestimate Retaliation
Wolpaw J, Saddawi‑Konefka D, Dwivedi P, Toy S. doi:10.46374/volxxi-issue4-wolpaw
The question
Constructive feedback, meaning feedback that tells a trainee what they did not do well and what they need to work to improve, helps people learn, but trainees rarely receive it. Earlier research has linked faculty reluctance to fear of damaging the relationship, limited skill, and lack of time. Wolpaw and colleagues asked whether anesthesiology faculty know how much residents want this kind of feedback, and whether faculty believe residents do not want constructive feedback or would retaliate against faculty who give it.
Between January and March 2019, the team surveyed anesthesiology residents and teaching faculty at two large academic medical centers. Both surveys showed the same four realistic examples of written constructive feedback. Residents were asked how they would respond to such feedback, and faculty were asked how likely they thought residents would be to want it. Of 156 residents, 116 responded (74%), and of 260 faculty, 127 responded (49%).
What it found
- Of residents who answered the question, 83 of 95 (87%) said they would want feedback like the examples. Of faculty, 67 of 112 (60%) thought residents would want it.
- Two residents (2%) said they would be somewhat likely to retaliate, defined as lowering their evaluation of the faculty member, and none said extremely likely. Another 16% were neutral, 20% said somewhat unlikely, and 62% said extremely unlikely. Meanwhile, 34 of 112 faculty (30%) named fear of retaliation as a barrier.
- Only 38 of 120 faculty (32%) said they were likely to put improvement feedback in writing, compared with 80 of 120 (67%) in person.
- Residents expected to be more upset by written than by in-person feedback. For written feedback, 23% said they would be somewhat likely and 3% extremely likely to be upset with the faculty member; in person, 4% said somewhat likely and none said extremely likely.
- Faculty described barriers including lack of time, too little time working with each resident, lack of confidence and skill, fear of negative reactions, and a sense that feedback would not change anything. For written feedback, some worried about leaving a permanent negative record in the resident’s file.
The paper’s abstract reports that 88% of residents would want such feedback and that 98% said they would not retaliate. The figures above come from the results section, which reports 87% (83 of 95) and breaks the retaliation answers into the categories shown, including the 16% who were neutral.
Why it matters
Fewer faculty in this study thought residents would want constructive feedback than residents themselves reported. Of faculty who answered, 30% named fear of retaliation as a barrier, while 2% of residents said they would be somewhat likely to retaliate. The authors suggest that making written feedback easier to give and building faculty trust that retaliation is unlikely may increase how much constructive feedback faculty provide. They note that prospective studies would be needed to test this, because stated barriers do not always reflect actual ones.
The findings come from anonymous surveys at two academic centers and reflect what residents predicted they would do, not observed behavior.
How to cite it
Wolpaw J, Saddawi-Konefka D, Dwivedi P, Toy S. Faculty underestimate resident desire for constructive feedback and overestimate retaliation. J Educ Perioper Med. 2019;21(4):E634. doi:10.46374/volxxi-issue4-wolpaw
More on the publications page. The complete record is on PubMed and ORCID.