Perspective · Academic Medicine · 2016
Changing Physician Behavior With Implementation Intentions: Closing the Gap Between Intentions and Actions
Saddawi‑Konefka D, Schumacher DJ, Baker KH, Charnin JE, Gollwitzer PM. doi:10.1097/ACM.0000000000001172
The question
Continuing medical education (CME) improves medical knowledge, yet even well-intentioned physicians have difficulty changing their practice, and the article notes that patients receive just over half of recommended care. Undergraduate and graduate medical education (medical school and the training that follows it) face a similar challenge in developing behaviors that benefit patients and society. Strong intentions alone are only a modest predictor of reaching a goal. The empirical studies the authors cite find that intentions account for no more than 28% of the variance in behavior. This perspective argues that a strategy from cognitive psychology, called implementation intentions, holds substantial promise for medical education.
What it argues
This is a perspective article. It reports no new data and instead reviews research on a strategy that has been extensively studied in cognitive psychology. An implementation intention is an “if-then” plan that names a future situation and a planned response. A goal intention only states the desired behavior (“I intend to read more about critical care”). An implementation intention adds when and where (“If I finish dinner before 9 pm, then I will read for 30 minutes from my critical care textbook”).
- The authors summarize a meta-analysis of nearly 100 studies in which implementation intentions had a medium to large effect on reaching goals (d = 0.65), beyond the effect of goal intentions alone. In one study they describe, 91% of undergraduates given a motivational strategy plus their own if-then plans exercised in the following week, compared with 35% of those given the motivational strategy alone and 38% of a control group.
- They explain the mechanism. Naming a situation in advance makes a person more likely to notice it when it arises, and the plan strengthens the link between that situation and the intended response, so the behavior becomes more automatic.
- They describe what makes plans work better. Plans help most with challenging goals. Triggers should be unambiguous and common, and responses should be feasible and useful. Plans that replace or ignore an unwanted behavior work better than plans that only forbid it. Plans do not work when commitment to the goal is low, so they have been combined with motivational strategies. The authors single out one such pairing, mental contrasting with implementation intentions, also called WOOP (Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan), because of the growing body of research on it.
- They caution that if-then plans do not produce perfect follow-through, and that people may not perceive the improvement. For that reason they recommend that studies in medical education measure objective outcomes over participants’ perceptions.
- They offer example plans across the six competency domains of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, at the levels of medical school, residency, and CME. Educators could hand out if-then plans alongside lectures or quality improvement efforts, or train learners to write their own and review them in mentor meetings.
Why it matters
To the authors’ knowledge, no studies had yet examined implementation intentions in medical education, although they had been used to help patients with health goals and to help students in schools and universities meet academic goals. The article sets out a research agenda, including a comparative design in which some residents are trained to set goals and others to form implementation intentions. The authors argue that if-then plans could help learners reach their learning goals and might narrow the gap between education and practice, and that further investigation is warranted.
How to cite it
Saddawi-Konefka D, Schumacher DJ, Baker KH, Charnin JE, Gollwitzer PM. Changing physician behavior with implementation intentions: closing the gap between intentions and actions. Acad Med. 2016;91(9):1211-1216. doi:10.1097/ACM.0000000000001172
More on the publications page. The complete record is on PubMed and ORCID.